Tap here to turn on desktop notifications to get the news sent straight to you.
James Orlando, Associate Attorney This report provides a concise overview of 1 the Reid method of interrogation, 2 critiques of the Reid method, and 3 alternative interrogation techniques.
Reid and Associates, Inc. According to the company's website, overlaw enforcement and security professionals have attended the company's interview and interrogation training programs since they were first offered in Some critics contend that the Reid Technique is premised on certain assumptions about human behavior that are not supported by empirical evidence, and that the technique may lead to false confessions.
The company contends that critics mischaracterize the Reid Technique and that false confessions are caused by interrogators applying inappropriate methods not endorsed by the company. Following is a brief summary of these components; more information is available on the company's website.
Factual Analysis The Reid website describes factual analysis as: Consequently, factual analysis relies not only on crime scene analysis, but also on information learned about each suspect.
The Reid website states that the BAI: In addition, the BAI facilitates the eventual interrogation of guilty suspects. The investigator tells the suspect that the evidence demonstrates the person's guilt. If the person's guilt seems clear to the investigator, the statement should be unequivocal.
The investigator then presents a moral justification theme for the offense, such as placing the moral blame on someone else or outside circumstances.
The investigator presents the theme in a monologue and in sympathetic manner. When the suspect asks for permission to speak at this stage likely to deny the accusationsthe investigator should discourage allowing the suspect to do so. When attempts at denial do not succeed, a guilty suspect often makes objections to support a claim of innocence e.
The investigator should generally accept these objections as if they were truthful, rather than arguing with the suspect, and use the objections to further develop the theme. Procurement and retention of suspect's attention. The investigator must procure the suspect's attention so that the suspect focuses on the investigator's theme rather than on punishment.
One way the investigator can do this is to close the physical distance between himself or herself and the suspect. Handling the suspect's passive mood. Presenting an alternative question. Having the suspect orally relate various details of the offense. After the suspect accepts one side of the alternative thus admitting guiltthe investigator should immediately respond with a statement of reinforcement acknowledging that admission.
The investigator then seeks to obtain a brief oral review of the basic events, before asking more detailed questions.
Converting an oral confession to a written confession. The investigator must convert the oral confession into a written or recorded confession. The website provides some guidelines, such as repeating Miranda warnings, avoiding leading questions, and using the suspect's own language.
Below, we briefly describe some criticisms of the Reid Technique, as well as responses to such criticisms by Reid and Associates, Inc.Two alternative interrogation techniques are (1) Preparation and Planning, Engage and Explain, Account, Closure and Evaluate (PEACE), a less confrontational method used in England, and (2) the Kinesic Interview, a method that focuses on recognizing deception.
If "effective" means that they led to the acquisition of vital intelligence, then I would say that none of them were effective. The "enhanced interrogation techniques" were designed to quickly extract vital intelligence from terrorist suspects and detainees in order to prevent future terrorist attacks.
A new interviewing technique is gaining acceptance as an effective way to discover the truth without creating false witnesses.
The PEACE (Preparation and Planning, Engage and Explain, Account, Closure and Evaluate) method is being applied in the UK, Denmark, New Zealand and a few other places. The Humane Interrogation Technique That Actually Works A study finds that confessions are four times more likely when interrogators adopt a respectful stance toward detainees and build rapport, instead of torturing.
Matthew Alexander talked about interrogation benjaminpohle.com Alexander is the former senior military interrogator who led the interrogation team in Iraq that found Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, the former. Dec 11, · That surprising and alarming conclusion led to recommendations that the government investigate effective, ethical interrogation techniques.